Créer un test
Connectez-vous !

Cliquez ici pour vous connecter
Nouveau compte
4 millions de comptes créés

100% gratuit !
[Avantages]


- Accueil
- Accès rapides
- Imprimer
- Livre d'or
- Plan du site
- Recommander
- Signaler un bug
- Faire un lien




Publicités :





Recommandés :

- Jeux gratuits
- Nos autres sites

   



Reported speech/help

Forum > English only || Bottom

[POST A NEW REPLY] [Subscribe to this topic]


Reported speech/help
Message from mohammad51 posted on 09-07-2019 at 21:14:02 (D | E | F)
Hello
Please could you help with this sentence ?
Direct speech >> “My mum told me to come home.
Indirect >>> She said (that) her mum told her to go home.

I noticed it was answered online and copied it here.
Why do they change 'come home to go home' ?
Thanks for any reply.

-------------------
Edited by lucile83 on 09-07-2019 22:11


Re: Reported speech/help from gerondif, posted on 09-07-2019 at 22:40:23 (D | E)
Hello
With said in a past tense, it should have been :
She said (that) her mum had told her to go home.
Come in the mother's mouth means to come to her. That action reported by a third person can be seen as go but come wouldn't have been wrong



Re: Reported speech/help from here4u, posted on 10-07-2019 at 12:44:26 (D | E)
Hello!
A strange direct speech and a strange indirect speech too, in the original sentences!

Please could you help with this sentence ?
Direct speech >> “My mum told me to come home.(1)
Indirect >>> She said (that) her mum told her to go home.
I noticed it was answered online and (I?) copied it (t)here.
Why do they change 'come home to go home' ?

I totally agree with gerondif !

(1) In the direct speech it should be: My Mum said to me: "Come home!"
Indirect speech: She said that her Mum had told her to go home!



Re: Reported speech/help from mohammad51, posted on 10-07-2019 at 15:13:39 (D | E)
Hello
I agree with you both.
That " come home" becomes " go home" when it is reported by a third person.
Then the writer or one who conveys the reported speech said:
She said that her mum had told her to go home. I see Go home is better than " come home" because she goes not comes.
The mother asked her saying " come"
It is answered online in one a good site.
Many thanks for you both.





[POST A NEW REPLY] [Subscribe to this topic]


Forum > English only










Partager : Facebook / Google+ / Twitter / ... 


> INDISPENSABLES : TESTEZ VOTRE NIVEAU | GUIDE DE TRAVAIL | NOS MEILLEURES FICHES | Les fiches les plus populaires | Aide/Contact

> COURS ET TESTS : Abréviations | Accents | Accords | Adjectifs | Adverbes | Alphabet | Animaux | Argent | Argot | Articles | Audio | Auxiliaires | Chanson | Communication | Comparatifs/Superlatifs | Composés | Conditionnel | Confusions | Conjonctions | Connecteurs | Contes | Contraires | Corps | Couleurs | Courrier | Cours | Dates | Dialogues | Dictées | Décrire | Démonstratifs | Ecole | Etre | Exclamations | Famille | Faux amis | Films | Formation | Futur | Fêtes | Genre | Goûts | Grammaire | Guide | Géographie | Heure | Homonymes | Impersonnel | Infinitif | Internet | Inversion | Jeux | Journaux | Lettre manquante | Littérature | Magasin | Maison | Majuscules | Maladies | Mots | Mouvement | Musique | Mélanges | Méthodologie | Métiers | Météo | Nature | Nombres | Noms | Nourriture | Négations | Opinion | Ordres | Participes | Particules | Passif | Passé | Pays | Pluriel | Politesse | Ponctuation | Possession | Poèmes | Pronominaux | Pronoms | Prononciation | Proverbes | Prépositions | Présent | Présenter | Quantité | Question | Relatives | Sports | Style direct | Subjonctif | Subordonnées | Synonymes | Temps | Tests de niveau | Tous les tests | Traductions | Travail | Téléphone | Vidéo | Vie quotidienne | Villes | Voitures | Voyages | Vêtements


> INFORMATIONS : Copyright - En savoir plus, Aide, Contactez-nous [Conditions d'utilisation] [Conseils de sécurité] Reproductions et traductions interdites sur tout support (voir conditions) | Contenu des sites déposé chaque semaine chez un huissier de justice | Mentions légales / Vie privée / Cookies.
| Cours et exercices d'espagnol 100% gratuits, hors abonnement internet auprès d'un fournisseur d'accès.